Making a S'more which includes the standard items, Chocolate, Marshmallow and Graham Cracker.

It would become Un-S'morethentic when someone replaces a standard item with some other form of similar item. For example the graham cracker is removed and replaced with a Hob nob biscuit.
Make mine S'morethentic please.

I only want one if it's going to be S'morethentic.

No Chessy, I don't want it, that is totally Un-S'morethentic.
by S'mores President June 6, 2014
Get the S'morethentic mug.