When a band/artist is played on the radio so much that that song/artist becomes hated, even if it/they are actually pretty good. I swear, overplay is not the artist's fault, just those crappy DJs that can't get their hands on anything better to play. Victims include:
Nickelback
Creed
Hinder
Slipknot
3Oh!3
Radio-only listener: Man, I fucking hate Nickelback!
Me: Don't say that! Nickelback is an awesome band. Many people like just suffer from Primary Overplay Syndrome.
by bbtdgfan123 December 20, 2010
Get the Primary Overplay Syndrome mug.
A potentially painful action that arises when a man forgets that he only has a short penis. Sometimes the recipient is the one who overplays the stroke due to over zealousness.
"Are you okay, Harvey? Did you overplay your stroke? It looks like your penis is broken!"
by 556fmj April 6, 2008
Get the overplay your stroke mug.
Overplayed his punt; (v) When someone does something that ends up way more remarkable than his initial effort.
When you see a total dork-ass feeb with a hot chick, you say; Wow, that dude really overplayed his punt to end up with her!

It's like when a football team recovers the ball and scores on a kick away.

When a guy pulls of a terrible pick up line, but gets laid anyway.
by Reverend Ron October 30, 2010
Get the overplayed his punt mug.
Man, Kamala's attack there in the debate was really overplayed.
by 642946 October 18, 2019
Get the overplay mug.